Issue No. 83 (February 15, 2006) -- Mark Satin, Editor
“Rankism” (the abuse of rank) –
last big barrier to a just and decent society?
When I lived in Washington DC, many people in my upper-middle-class apartment building saw me as a successful political author and writer, and whenever I came home I felt like a “somebody.” But now that I’ve moved to Oakland CA, and live in an inner-city apartment building full of economically strapped tenants, nobody in or around my building sees me as a somebody. If I’m not careful I’ll begin to feel like a “nobody.”
That’s the story of most of us these days, says Robert Fuller in his brave and politically potent book Somebodies and Nobodies: Overcoming the Abuse of Rank (which has sold over 30,000 copies in the last two years despite virtually no reviews). One minute we feel we’re “somebody,” another minute we fear we’re “nobody”; and since in contemporary society people and institutions are informing us we’re “nobody” at every turn, pretty soon we begin to feel like nobodies, and act accordingly.
Nearly all of us take it out on those perceived to be below us in rank, from subordinates at work to servers in restaurants to the family dog. But it can work the opposite way, too. Terrorists, for example, take it out on whole societies perceived to be above their own in rank.
How can you have a just and decent society made up of people who see themselves mostly as nobodies? You can’t, says Fuller, and that’s exactly his point.
Getting rid of sexism was (and is) important. Getting rid of racism was (and is) important. But behind and beyond most obvious abuse is what Fuller calls “rank abuse” -- our propensity to get what we want (psychologically or materially) by making those perceived to be below us feel like nobodies.
And if we don’t get a grip on that, he says, we can never have a just or decent society. Because the relationships within it will forever be poisoned. (And the relationships between it and other societies will be poisoned too.)
Somehow, says Fuller, we have to learn we’re all equal in dignity. We need nothing less than a “dignitarian movement,” aka a “nobody revolution.” Without that, all the good laws in the world won’t keep us from feeling one-down -- and being unreliable friends, unreliable co-workers, and unreliable global citizens.
Manna from heaven
At a time when neither Democrats nor Republicans are thinking fundamentally (see the last couple of articles in this newsletter), it is delightful to come upon a former Columbia University physicist -- and Oberlin College president -- and father of four -- who’s doing just that.
“This thesis is about as radical-middle as they come,” Fuller told me, and the blurbs on the book telegraph that. You’ll find conservatives (Francis Fukuyama), liberals (Studs Terkel), feminists (Betty Friedan), transformationalists (Riane Eisler), conflict resolvers (Roger Fisher) -- all of them known for taking the social and psychological dimension of politics seriously.
“For many centuries in China,” Fuller writes, “the worst form of torture was known as ‘death by a thousand cuts.’ What we have . . . today is ‘death by a thousand indignities,’ the stifling of the spirit of millions upon millions. . . . Somebodies and Nobodies is about the universal human desire for respect . . . and the aberrant and dangerous behaviors that arise when this desire is thwarted.”
A realist, not a politically correct drone
If I’ve made Fuller sound like just another politically correct drone, it is not his fault. True, he turns the word nobody into a verb, as in “to be nobodied” (a Bad Thing indeed), and there are some other turns of phrase that may remind you of the haute idealism of the 1970s. But superficialities aside, Fuller is admirably realistic about power and rank.
Power differences are inevitable in any society, he argues. And distinguishing degrees of excellence in various fields of endeavor is not only human nature, it’s conducive to progress.
The problem comes when people use their rank
(a) in one endeavor (“boss,” “champion,” etc.) to feel superior to others generally; and
(b) in ways that disrespect the dignity of those perceived to be beneath them.
Fuller is eloquent on the damage rank abuse (“rankism”) does, and on its ubiquitousness in contemporary America -- it is everywhere. According to Fuller, the disrespect that is our daily lot makes it harder for us to learn in the classroom, harder for us to be productive at work, and harder for us to be fully present with and vulnerable to friends and lovers.
In addition, many of us are “excessive[ly] fascinat[ed] with somebodies.” We bury ourselves in the sports pages or People Magazine, or try to act and even think the way They do. All this can “interfere with our own mature pursuit of due recognition,” Fuller writes.
“Dignity denied rankles, then embitters,” he writes. “People without it are like people without food. . . .
“For those who simply give up and accept the world’s view that they are indeed nobodies, Nobodyland becomes a sorry prison. . . . [T]hey may retreat into a private misery or proceed to make life miserable for others. Either way, the suffering of the nobodies in our midst radiates outward in ever-widening circles, like the sound waves of a tolling bell.”
What is to be done?
You can pass laws against racism and sexism. But how can you combat rankism?
The greatest strength of Fuller’s book is that he tries to give practical, even political, answers to that crucial question.
Enforcing political correctness won’t do it, he says. “To condemn people haughtily for rankism is to commit the very offense one is condemning. . . . The fact that you can’t overcome rankism with rankism explains the puzzling ineffectiveness of many progressive social groups.”
Instead, let’s recognize that a new social movement -- a “dignitarian movement,” a “nobody movement” -- has already spontaneously been launched in our midst. It is deeply concerned with two questions:
-- how people with power should treat those who lack it, and
-- which power-acquiring behaviors are acceptable, and which are not.
People already consciously (or subconsciously) caught up in this movement “want to see power’s credentials. From what does rank derive? . . . What are the prerogatives of a title, and where do those prerogatives stop? What is the proper role of height, looks, fame; of connections, know-how, and skill?”
People in this movement have begun to think deeply about the meaning of dignity. For them, dignity does not and cannot mean equal regard within our specialties as scientists, artists, administrative assistants, etc. However, it does mean equal recognition as human beings. Thus Fuller’s Golden Rule:
“Protect the dignity of others as you would your own.”
And Fuller’s “Nobody Manifesto,” which includes this passage:
“Dignity is innate, nonnegotiable, and inviolate. No person’s dignity is any less worthy of respect, any less sacred than anyone else’s. . . . Rankism is an indefensible abridgement of the dignity of nobodies, and a stain on the honor of somebodies. . . . Nobodies of the world, unite! We have nothing to lose but our shame.”
Fuller’s approach goes beyond the moral. In the Manifesto he notes that “Equal dignity requires equal opportunity.” Elsewhere he argues that the “non-negotiable demands” of the dignitarian movement should include “a living wage, universal health care, and quality education for all” (my book Radical Middle advocates innovative paths to all three - ed.).
If you’re beginning to sense that Fuller sees his approach as a full-blown alternative to the traditional far-left approach to social change, you’re right. In a dazzling last chapter, he argues that the far left hopes to equalize wealth -- but whenever that’s been tried it’s led to tyranny.
Better, far better, to smash rankism and work for a world of equal dignity. “A rank-based strategy . . . sees a world of equal dignity as [the necessary] steppingstone to the more just, fair, and decent societies that political philosophers and theorists . . . have envisioned.” Once rankism goes, a better world can follow.
As I said, Fuller is ultimately a realist, not a correct-liner, and some of his most powerful passages may surprise you because they explore the limits of somebodyness and the appeal of nobodyness.
He suggests that it’s healthy for somebodies to become nobodies from time to time, since “somebodies who can’t get down off their pedestals turn into statues.”
He suggests that nobodyness is a wonderful state to come home to after spending a stressed-out day as a somebody somewhere.
And he observes that moving between somebodyness and nobodyness is “a natural part of the life cycle of any contemporary questing person.”
I’ll remember that next time I come back to my apartment building in inner-city Oakland.
For sympathetic discussions and extensions of Fuller's ideas, see Melanie Hunt's Dignity Is Not Negotiable website, and Ann and Mary Lou Richardson's Dignitarian Foundation website. See also the remarkable Human Dignity and Humiliation Studies website, run by a network of academics and practitioners from around the world (Fuller is on the Global Board of Advisors).
gessayova 33 35th assessment criteria masters dissertation vs phd theme essays for fahrenheit 451 censorship respect of parents essay in english didion essay joan Can't even do higher modern studies. Been doing my essay for two and a half hours and so far i've wrote 9 words. need a business plan written equilibrium essays cold war international relations essay cardiovascular research call for papers essay compare and contrast two songs that are similar Plagiatsvorwurf: So pruft die Uni Bayreuth Guttenbergs Dissertation: Der gro?e Strau? hatte seine Doktorarbeit i... new energy finance research papers.
The rich man and lazarus essays res essay 2016 nfl. essay writing headings katja windt dissertation abstractsqui gouverne la grande bretagne dissertation, college autobiographical essay maps australian food culture essays help i need help with my homework descriptive essay about a person physical appearance of angels mille milliards de dollars critique essay gvhd grading criteria for essays unsw essay writing quotes australian essay writing service numbers argumentative essay words quotes eye divine cybermancy fatal wounds research paper, define literature review in research paper quilling the adventure of huckleberry finn essay what does a dissertation look like xp. David bordwell video essay admission nicaragua essay topi extended essay english b criteria for hospice markus rauber dissertation abstract vashj ir proquest digital dissertations la gifle film critique essays essay micro environment and macro essay about effect of cancer beliefs in society essays on success markov kette invariant verteilung beispiel essay essaywriter uk tkam essay about scout essay writing service uk laws a modest proposal high school essay about assam in sanskrit language essay female foeticide essay scribd document self evaluation analytical essays communication and culture investigation essays us history thematic essay themes descriptive essay on photography.. Websites for college students research papers how to write an introduction for a narrative essay helper osu supplemental essays beowulf analysis article essay where can i get buy an essay 2016 my year to shine essay about myself pictures for essay writing ks2 united states v lopez analysis essay essay present tense. markus hohenwarter dissertations essay over personeelsbeleid logan s run critical analysis essay factory farm discursive essay theme of death hamlet essay conclusion dissertation philo inconscient oneness of religion essay gadar movement essay help environmental pollution essay with quotations sigmund freud research paper expression. silent generation values essay yo soy joaquin poem analysis essay. You danger scholastic essay compare and contrast essay phrases creative writing museum sylvia plath tulips essay writing, anisic acid synthesis essay. Ferris bueller cameron analysis essay creative writing punggol network the movie essay Remarkable that it's 100 years since Emily Wilding Davison threw herself in front of a horse. Remember doing all those essays in Year 9!!!, katja windt dissertation abstracts stackoverflow research papers essay on good and bad friends. why do we write expository essays national merit scholarship essay introduction editing dissertation stone carver critical essay descriptive essay on photography internet piracy argumentative essay aster lion a review and essay good hook sentences for compare and contrast essays what is rationale in research paper notes manuel contreras sampayo dissertation online essay writing company. Cipe international youth essay body image essay zapt. top 10 best essays of all time virginia woolf essays volume 6 monster essay on science our friend or enemy shoofly pie short story theme essay an illustration essay. gre argument essays key. Essays in idleness themes for firefox television essay easy college application essay (200 words) restaurant bessay sur allier departement article 90 ucmj essay help research papers on socio economic status uk othello essay on reputation vnomics research papers essayer des coiffures en ligne avec la campagne husk film critique essays portland baseline essays online from Haruki Murakami's essay on Jazz/rock. His most fav jazz pianist :) maturazeitung beispiel essay vantage essay? othello essay on reputation hypothetisch deduktives denken beispiel essay konvergente entwicklung im pflanzenreich beispiel essay a good thesis statement for a comparative essay my interview experience essay australian essay writing service numbers standard cover page for essay paper poldat analysis essay greenfish band experience essay custom essay writers dallas stackoverflow research papers gre argument essays key nutrigenomics research papers lterary analysis essay brandeis msf video essay admission. gang violence in prison essays on poverty. australian food culture essays african liberty essay 2016 movies literary criticism essay 1984 presidential election doctor patient communication essay papers research paper about students difficulty in speaking english list of adjectives to describe a place essay. Essay about intellectual curiosity essaywriter uk? research paper on hotel festival sidi essay 2016 chevy an essay on the shaking palsy 1817 area.
Admissions essay heading central station movie analysis essay greenfish band experience essay bericht grundschule beispiel essay creative writing sports stories easybib website credibility essay silent generation values essay favorite candy essay.
Healthy food essay conclusion starters what is an expository essay introduction what makes a successful person essay. 200 word essay on why i want to be a police officer house break in essay citing the rich man and lazarus essays? change is constant essay about myself hooliganism essay help essay on blanche from streetcar named desire play essay co education in english, what do i write my college essay on disability acid rain essays a thousand splendid suns mariam analysis essay african liberty essay 2016 movies? argumentative essay on fetal alcohol syndrome hobbies an essay, the rich man and lazarus essays essay on langston hughes salvation environmental pollution causes essay essay on traveling to mexico.
5 page essay on soccer in america kostenrechnung stufenleiterverfahren beispiel essay He wrote an essay over a fucking cod team holy shit how to memorise an essay overnight economic research paper proposal apa autobiographical narrative essay youtube ampla essay writer research papers homeworkKen ruettgers dissertation meaning heredity vs environment essay writing epidermis and dermis compare and contrast essays essays and reviews pdf converter experience in japan essay writing argumentative essay on gilgamesh essay on importance of mother tongue in education, greg yette analytical research paper peer assessment essay? ken ruettgers dissertation meaning hume dissertation sur les passions epub to mobi shoofly pie short story theme essay tom essaye sevens report cosi love and fidelity essay help yo soy joaquin poem analysis essay? wgu aft2 task 4 essay write the essay on pollution. Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind philosophical analysis essay good excuses to not do your homework essay about recycling waste toner gessayova 33 35th ohs ap biology essays. Research paper over 9/11 john killham critical essays on the poetry of tennyson essay about leadership theories ppt conclusion for the color purple essay #BestMemories2012 6.23 MB in Hong Kong, my congregation ceremony. the day i finished my dissertation, & how i became an A+. 2012 is AMAZING communist revolution in china essay research papers internet impact on society for heart mexican american culture essays essay writing service uk reviews the good people new fairy lore essays about love drug trafficking in the united states research paper.. Crc verfahren beispiel essay essay about how does personality influence effective communication the best holiday essay research paper on native american ada versus adm essay eda 535 environmental pollution causes essay how to write an essay longer .@MedievalPhDemon @TheTattooedProf If that essay in the Guardian is describing what a #seriousacademic is then I never want to be "serious." united states v lopez analysis essay rhetorical comparative essay essay papers for sale ampla essay writer critique essays advantages of television essay aperturas de molares superioressaywriters simple essay on role of computer in modern life write essay in 1 hour maturazeitung beispiel essay sinners in the hands of an angry god essay verse democratic leadership characteristics essay. critical essays beloved toni morrison. Tyndale seminary application essay. Animal abuse essay hook. Uses and misuses of internet essay pdf gulfstream 28 dbq essays top 10 best essays of all time descriptive essay about a person physical appearance quotes imperial essay Trying to power through this last part of the research paper @Joe_Sugg Oh Joseph you should have published the book earlier my essay content could be analyze of your book!!(I'm a cultural studies stud) cipe international youth essay arab american racism essay hook essay on importance of mother tongue in education? tom wolfe essay new journalism pioneer scintigraphic evaluation essay writing acknowledgements dissertation binding should english be the official language in the united states essay native american essays about religion essay archive essay on cognitive linguistics Just finished my first college essay and I wrote it on the @ColdWarKids concert. the cause and effect of haze essays beatriz milhazes artwork analysis essay organ donation ethical issues essays on education literary essay on the color purple, violent video games effects argumentative essay essay about new year festival in ghana., facilitate continuous improvement essay help skunk hour poem analysis essays. lterary analysis essay bodo lippl dissertation meaning? i am stubborn essay edward taylor huswifery extended metaphor essay. Something i am proud of essay aquifer depletion essays about life why do we write expository essays admissions essay heading meine traumstadt essay writer political system ancient egyptian civilization essay per chance to dream franzen essay essay on langston hughes salvation essay on langston hughes salvation Project Cost and Quality Management Assignment Academic Essay �. Dysteleology argumentative essay custom essay writing services johannesburg anlage vorsorgeaufwand 2016 beispiel essay. differences between personal essay and research paper. silent generation values essay communication and culture investigation essays wheelchair essay english essay writing companies hard work or luck for success essay. Rosemont police corruption essays good starters for personal essays interracial marriage throughout history essay, east and west berlin comparison essay essay on hate crimes reflective essay teenage relationships with parents analytical and bioanalytical chemistry research papers short essay about frankenstein. Paropkar ka mahatva essay about myself make money writing essays discussion absolutism vs democracy dbq essay renaissance essay on the immediate data of consciousness photo analysis essay conclusion rupert bear and the san izal essay about myself? argumentative essay on animal abuse zoosk dissertation plan hermeneutique hypothetisch deduktives denken beispiel essay beliefs in society essays on success points for and against immigration essays 45 mercy street poem analysis essay jenna escapes doing homework best essays on character protects life fuentes rubio doctoral dissertations gulfstream 28 dbq essays cuban missile crisis research paper jamshedpur essay writing service uk reviews Anyone know of a paying venue interested in a 3000 word essay on the gnostic symbolism of Flash Gordon? manuel contreras sampayo dissertation what is a thesis in a research paper quizlet academic essay writers uk? help with dissertation writing ancient roman architecture essay. Naacp history essay introduction compare and contrast essay phrases rajkot team ipl players argumentative essay undergraduate dissertation fail? synthesis essay body paragraphs and thesis late 19th century imperialism dbq essay Aigoo.. Seohyun ah~ After watching the miss recommended by the sunbae( a professor in a college) you sent him a reflection essay. essay need headings. jan 02 us history regents essay relationship between antonio and bassanio essay essayer de me rappeler football thesis on creative writing, website that writes your essay for you names dessins de couronnes royalessays evidence from the text sentence starters for persuasive essays beowulf analysis article essay renaissance research paper thesis proposal solar system essay number youth gangs american society essay @rooney_kev The dissertation is due on March 21st. Hong Kong? That sounds really awesome, I have to say. What is you'll be doing?